Every innovation of Web3 protocol standards is not only a technological leap, but also a catalyst for the birth of new models and new asset forms for the entire digital economy. Innovation in standards, especially in the representation of assets, interoperability, and user interaction, provides developers with the opportunity to build more complex, responsive, and user-friendly applications. With the development of blockchain technology, we have witnessed the evolution from single-function tokens to multi-function smart contract platforms, and each step is accompanied by the introduction of new protocol standards and the improvement of old standards.
This Bing Ventures research article introduces new standards in the field of semi-fungible tokens (such as ERC-404, TinySPL, and Asteroids) and related representative projects, and conducts a certain evaluation of these standards.
We believe that the innovation of semi-fungible tokens should consider key issues in four directions, and their performance in practical applications and market acceptance should also be considered in specific evaluations.
By promoting innovation in these key areas, semi-fungible tokens will be able to optimize the performance of existing technologies and platforms, and also open up new application scenarios and market opportunities, ultimately promoting the healthy and sustainable development of the entire blockchain industry.
First, ERC-404 tokens introduce the concept of semi-fungibility. Semi-fungible tokens are a brave attempt to find a middle ground between fully fungible (like ERC-20 tokens) and unique (like ERC-721 tokens). However, this attempt brings not only technical challenges, but also raises questions about market acceptance. Although it theoretically provides a more flexible ownership model for the asset, in practice, this semi-homogeneity can lead to market confusion, and investors may have difficulty judging the true value of the tokens.
Semi-fungibility
ERC-404 tokens introduce a new concept of semi-fungibility to the blockchain ecosystem. By building a bridge between the fungibility of ERC-20 tokens and the uniqueness of ERC-721 tokens, ERC-404 provides a versatile solution for digital assets.
Fragmented Ownership
The standard allows for fragmented ownership of unique digital assets, such as art or virtual real estate. It democratizes access to high-value assets by making them more accessible and liquid.
Independent Trading
The dual nature of ERC-404 tokens and their corresponding NFTs enables independent trading, enhancing the liquidity and utility of digital asset markets.
Each ERC-404 token is intrinsically linked to a unique NFT, creating a symbiotic relationship between fungible and non-fungible assets. The minting of an NFT results in the creation of a corresponding fungible token, and vice versa. The splitting of a token results in the destruction of the associated NFT, while the merging of enough split shares to form a full token triggers the minting of a new NFT.
Lack of Formal Review and Security Audits
The biggest risk comes from the fact that ERC-404 tokens have not undergone rigorous security audits. Without these audits, there may be undiscovered vulnerabilities that malicious actors could exploit, leading to loss of funds or other security vulnerabilities.
The innovative aspects of ERC-404, while promising, also introduce uncertainty. New code, especially code that has not been field-tested, has a higher risk of containing critical bugs or design flaws.
Compatibility
The official ERC standard benefits from widespread support from wallets, exchanges, and other infrastructure. ERC-404’s unofficial status may hinder its compatibility, limiting its usefulness and seamless interaction with the broader Ethereum ecosystem.
The unique mechanics of ERC-404 tokens may cause compatibility issues with existing smart contracts and dApps designed for ERC-20 and ERC-721 tokens. These issues can complicate their use in some applications or even prevent their use without significant modifications.
Community and Ecosystem Impacts
Adopting ERC-404 without going through a formal EIP process could encourage the proliferation of additional experimental standards without proper review. This can lead to a fragmented ecosystem with an increased risk of security incidents due to a lack of coordinated review and auditing.
Part of the strength of the Ethereum ecosystem is trust in its standards and governance processes. Bypassing these processes can undermine confidence among developers, investors, and users, potentially slowing innovation and adoption.
Bakery 404 represents a revolutionary advancement in democratizing token creation in the Ethereum blockchain ecosystem. By leveraging the unique properties of ERC-404 tokens, Bakery 404 provides a straightforward, easy-to-use, and fast platform for anyone interested in deploying custom tokens.
404Bakery’s Innovation
Bakery 404 simplifies the token creation process, making it accessible to a wide audience not just professional builders. This ease of accessibility is critical to fostering innovation and participation in the Ethereum ecosystem.
Main features
Through a streamlined process, users can create tokens by specifying properties such as name, ticker, and supply without writing any code.
Tokens can be deployed on the Ethereum mainnet in minutes, with plans to expand support to the Base and Arbitrum networks.
Using Telegram bots to guide the token creation process makes it more accessible to a broad user base, removing barriers to entry into the crypto space.
Bakery 404 Operation
The platform utilizes a smart Telegram bot that serves as an interactive guide to the token creation process. This approach not only simplifies the experience, but also adds a level of engagement that traditional token creation tools lack. Users are able to make decisions about the characteristics of their tokens through a conversational interface.
Step 1: Start a conversation with the bot Action: Open Telegram and find the 404 Bakery Deploy Bot using the link provided. Purpose: This initiates your interaction with the bot, which will guide you through the deployment process.
Step 2: Create a new Ethereum wallet Action: If you don’t have an Ethereum wallet, the bot will generate one for you. Ensure the provided private key is stored securely. Purpose: An Ethereum wallet is essential for managing your ERC-404 tokens and paying for deployment fees.
Step 3: Fund your wallet Action: Make sure you have at least 0.3 ETH in your newly created or existing Ethereum wallet. Purpose: ETH is used to pay for the gas fees associated with deploying your token on the Ethereum mainnet.
Step 4: Start deployment Action: Type /deploy in your chat with the bot to start the deployment process. Purpose: This command indicates to the bot that you are ready to proceed with creating your ERC-404 token.
Step 5: Provide ERC-404 Token Details Action: When prompted by the bot, enter the name and ticker symbol of your ERC-404 token. Purpose: These details personalize your token, making it identifiable on the blockchain.
Step 6: Add IPFS and Website Links Action: Provide an IPFS link containing the user’s token metadata, as well as a website link for the token. Purpose: The IPFS link hosts your token’s metadata in a decentralized manner, while the website link provides additional information about your tokens.
Step 7: Contract Deployment Action: Upon confirmation, the bot will deploy your ERC-404 token contract on the Ethereum mainnet. Purpose: This finalizes the creation of your token, making it usable for your intended purpose.
Tokenomics
Source: 404Bakery Doc
Token Holder Benefits
Holders of the $BAKE token are able to earn 50% of the revenue from transaction fees on the platform. This innovative model provides token holders with a passive income stream, directly tying the success of the Bakery404 platform to the financial well-being of its community.
Based on the groundbreaking DN404 technology, Asterix Labs is committed to redefining the landscape of digital assets and their underlying standards.
What is DN404
DN404 is a revolutionary token standard that challenges the established ERC404 and was created by a group of cryptocurrency enthusiasts. It is designed to provide similar benefits to ERC404, but with greater efficiency and lower transaction costs. By employing a dual-contract system that integrates an ERC-20-based divisible token share contract and a mirrored ERC-721 contract for unique NFTs, DN404 addresses the limitations of its predecessor while ensuring compatibility with existing token standards sex. This focus on efficiency and security quickly gained traction among developers and users seeking more sustainable decentralized NFT solutions.
DN404 Features
Unlike ERC404, which attempts to merge the ERC-20 and ERC-721 standards into a single contract, DN404 utilizes two contracts that are linked to each other. This approach simplifies the token creation process and minimizes potential vulnerabilities and security risks.
DN404 offers a competitive advantage in terms of transaction costs, with developers reporting average gas savings of approximately 20% compared to ERC404. This reduction is especially important in the Ethereum network, where gas fees can fluctuate wildly.
DN404’s separated contract structure provides enhanced security features, reducing the risk of potential vulnerabilities compared to ERC404’s single-contract approach.
DN404 prioritizes efficiency and security, providing a reliable framework for tokenization and asset management, making it a strong competitor to ERC404 within the Ethereum ecosystem.
Project performance
Source: Opensea,DEXTools
The NFT floor price is 0.9ETH. Although the trading volume is not large, the price of the token has risen more than 10 times since the issuance date.
As the first PFP project driven by the ERC404 token standard, DeFrog includes 10,000 uniquely designed DeFrogs, each of which offers a mix of rarity, artistic value and technological innovation.
Project Performance
Source: Opensea,DEXTools
As the first ERC 404 PFP project, it once had a tenfold increase in the early stage, and now it has fallen back to about two times.
ANON developed the ERC352 standard, a landmark innovation in the NFT ecosystem. This new standard aims to address and overcome limitations in previous NFT standards, including ERC721 and ERC1155, by introducing enhanced liquidity mechanisms, improved rarity features, and support for fractional ownership. The ERC352 standard introduced by ANON is based on the foundational principles of ERC404 and further pushes the boundaries of digital asset management and ownership possibilities.
Key Innovations
ANON’s ERC352 standard significantly reduces gas fees and enhances market liquidity and accessibility by integrating whitelist functionality to facilitate seamless interaction between ERC20 and ERC721 standards.
ERC352 solves one of the most pressing challenges in the NFT space: rarity management. Through complex contract mechanisms, it ensures that the rarity and uniqueness of each NFT is maintained, thus maintaining their value and appeal.
By enhancing the mechanism of token fragmentation, ERC352 opens up new opportunities for a wider range of investors to participate in the NFT market. Not only does this make the NFT more accessible, but it increases the rarity and value of the NFT by locking up the fraction before the entire token is available for purchase.
Project performance
Source: Opensea,DEXTools
The project NFT has no trading volume on Opensea, and the token was only hyped up to a tenfold increase when it was listed. Now it has fallen back to the opening price.
Alphabet leverages the ERC-404 token standard and cross-chain messaging to revolutionize the points ecosystem. Although the background of the founder is anonymous, he also has rich qualifications. Previously held roles on UNICEF’s encryption team and Deloitte’s encryption team.
Project Overview
Alphabet’s mission is to transform the way points programs are implemented, leveraging the ERC-404 standard to promote transparent, efficient and decentralized incentive schemes. This initiative not only seeks to decentralize points programs, but also aims to redefine their usefulness and accessibility on a global scale.
Inspired by ERC-404’s novel approach, which blends the fungible and non-fungible aspects of tokens, Alphabet plans to apply this standard to create a more fluid and versatile points system. The system aims to significantly reduce operating costs while increasing the liquidity and utility of points as incentives.
At its core, Alphabet is creating a new L1 blockchain specifically designed to run the points program. Alphabet’s primary L1 token holders can stake their tokens to earn fees for these programs, introducing a sustainable economic model that rewards participation and supports the ecosystem.
Alphabet also emphasizes community engagement and aesthetic appeal, with plans to refresh its art in the coming weeks. The project has allocated a significant marketing budget to ensure visibility and appeal within the crypto community, attracting key opinion leaders and movements to spread the message.
Goals and Vision
Alphabet aims to shift the paradigm of current points programs from centralized to decentralized, providing the protocol with a transparent and autonomous mechanism to incentivize and reward community participation.
By leveraging ERC-404 and cross-chain messaging, Alphabet seeks to bring traditional points programs to the blockchain, ensuring these incentives are accessible, transparent and efficient.
The project focuses on creating a gas fee efficient and composable ERC-404 standard that can be seamlessly integrated into different protocols and blockchains, facilitating a universal system for earning and distributing on-chain points.
Project performance
Source: Opensea,DEXTools
The project NFT has only a small amount of trading volume on Opensea, and the token was only hyped up to a tenfold increase when it was listed, and now it has fallen back to the opening price.
In October 2021, the Shib community introduced its first NFT collection, Shiboshis, including 10,000 male characters. Recently, SHEboshis marks an innovation in the women and NFT space, strongly supporting the future of NFTs within the Shib ecosystem. SHEboshis were developed using ERC-404 technology and are designed to expand the functionality and inclusivity of the Shib NFT space.
Mechanism
SHEboshis offer a unique distribution mechanism based on the number and length of Shiboshis held by a user, with Leash holders having priority when purchasing. However, due to a contract vulnerability, the initial phase was skipped and went straight to the public sale. These tokens, built on ERC-404 technology, are tradable and will be traded on Uniswap and Shibaswap.
Pairing Mechanism
Shib plans to introduce a pairing mechanism between Shiboshi and SHEboshis, implying the generation of future generations of NFTs/tokens. Specific details of this output have not yet been made public, with the feature expected to launch within the year.
Integration into Shiboshi Game
Similar to Shiboshis, SHEboshis will play a role in the Shiboshi game, a strategy game utilizing NFTs within the Shib ecosystem. This integration emphasizes the equal status and underlying value alignment between Shiboshis and SHEboshis.
Project performance
As a product officially launched by Shib, it is expected that there will be continued empowerment in the future, and the first generation of NFT series Shiboshis There was also a good increase in the early stage. The second-generation Sheboshis are relatively cheap, and the price may recover after the launch of ERC 404 transactions.
MINER is a collection of 10,000 avatars or equivalents made possible by the implementation of ERC-X, an experimental token standard. The standard distinguishes itself by offering a versatile approach to tokenization, combining features from several established ERC standards, including ERC20, ERC404, ERC721, ERC721A, ERC721Psi, ERC1155, and ERC1155Delta.
ERC-X optimizes the utility and efficiency of the token standard on the Ethereum network. Its design facilitates the integration of various standards into a unified framework, allowing a wide range of applications while maintaining fuel efficiency and scalability.
One of ERC-X’s signature features is its remarkable fuel efficiency. By optimizing transaction costs, ERC-X makes it possible to trade tokens with small capital, depending on Ethereum’s gas price. This efficiency contrasts with the recurring prohibitive transaction costs under the original standard, making ERC-X a practical solution for large-scale operations.
Although ERC-X has made significant progress in improving fuel efficiency and reducing transaction costs, this optimization may bring more complex underlying logic. This complexity not only presents a challenge for developers building applications on ERC-X, but may also increase the risk of security vulnerabilities, as more complex code is often more difficult to audit and verify.
ERC-X’s scalability is evident in its ability to support projects of any size, thanks to its flexible token/NFT ratio. This adaptability is further enhanced by its ability to render NFTs as ERC721 or ERC1155 tokens. Such flexibility ensures that ERC-X can cater for a wide range of applications, from simple token transfers to complex NFT integrations.
Although ERC-X has made contributions in improving the scalability and flexibility of tokens and NFTs, this cross-standard integration may also cause compatibility issues. Especially when interoperating with legacy standards and infrastructure, you may encounter unexpected technical obstacles. This requires a continuous update and adaptation process to ensure that ERC-X can run smoothly in the existing ecosystem.
Integrating elements of ERC1155Delta into ERC-X is a key innovation that provides a significant boost to the standard’s optimization capabilities. ERC1155Delta’s extension to the ERC1155 standard enables ERC-X to provide dual functionality; it supports the generation of both ERC721 and ERC1155 tokens, ensuring compatibility with markets that support either format.
Although integrating ERC1155Delta into ERC-X brings new innovations to the token standard and adds dual functionality, the complexity of this design may cause developers and users to encounter difficulties in understanding and using it in actual applications. on the difficulty. Especially for those users who are not familiar with the features of ERC1155Delta, understanding how to effectively utilize these features may require a certain learning curve.
ERC-X’s EasyLaunch feature simplifies the token launch process into just two steps: deployment and liquidity addition. This simplicity is a significant improvement over the more complex processes associated with other standards, which require multiple preliminary steps before adding liquidity. EasyLaunch therefore represents a significant advancement in making token launches more accessible and less time-consuming.
Although the EasyLaunch feature simplifies the token launch process, is it possible that this simplification obscures certain key considerations for token issuance? For example, considerations for liquidity management, security verification, and long-term token economics strategies may be overlooked because of the simplification of the process. Therefore, while EasyLaunch improves accessibility and efficiency, it also requires developers and project parties to be cautious when using it, ensuring that in-depth project planning and prudent security audits are not sacrificed.
Summary
Fragmented ownership: democratization or complexity?
The introduction of fragmented ownership, while intended to democratize access to high-value assets by lowering the barrier to entry, actually increases transaction and management complexity. The practicality of this approach is limited by users’ understanding and adaptability to such asset management, as well as the market’s demand for the liquidity of such fragmented assets.
Independent transactions: liquidity enhancer or potential source of chaos?
The dual nature of ERC-404 tokens and their NFTs, which are designed to enhance market liquidity, sounds exciting. But in reality, this may lead to market segmentation, with one part of the market focusing on traditional NFTs and the other pursuing the new model of ERC-404. This segmentation may lead to liquidity being actually diluted rather than enhanced.
In summary, ERC-404-related projects are still in their early stages. Although in the early stages, these projects experienced a certain appreciation due to the novelty of ERC-404 and the leadership of the leading project Pandora, the price then gradually fell back to near the opening price. In addition, ERC-404 has also spawned new standards such as ERC-352 and DN404. These projects demonstrate the bottom-up self-adjustment capabilities of the Ethereum ecosystem. This community-driven asset management approach has already established its user base. As long as the technology and user experience are continuously optimized in the future, it is expected to build a complete ecological sector.
Tiny SPL represents a new approach to solving the challenge of on-chain data storage costs within the Solana ecosystem through the use of innovative state compression technology.
Background
Solana implements a unique account model that includes a rent mechanism. Unlike Ethereum, which primarily charges transaction fees, Solana also imposes a rental fee on accounts to store data on the blockchain. This rent is calculated based on the account’s token balance and is intended to ensure efficient use of storage resources. Accounts that are unable to pay the rent may be deleted, although accounts with balances exceeding two years of rent are exempted. As technology advances and storage costs decrease, rental costs are expected to decline, although fluctuations in SOL prices may affect the actual cost burden on users.
Tiny SPL emerges as a smaller, more efficient iteration of the Solana Program Library (SPL) token standard. Its main innovation is the ability to enable token ownership without an associated rental cost, thanks to state compression. This approach significantly reduces on-chain storage requirements by leveraging Merkle trees to compress data verifiably into a single hash. This breakthrough has particular application in reducing the cost of minting NFTs on Solana by several orders of magnitude, as demonstrated by Helium Mobile, which minted nearly a million NFTs at a fraction of the traditional cost.
Differences between Tiny SPL tokens and standard SPL tokens:
By leveraging state compression, Tiny SPL tokens circumvent the need to pay rent, addressing one of the main costs associated with token ownership on Solana. NFT section visibility: Unlike regular tokens that appear in your wallet balance, Tiny SPL tokens are only visible in the NFT section, reflecting their unique approach to storage and management.
Tiny SPL introduces a unique token management experience, including a process for splitting and merging tokens. These operations are critical to adjusting the number of tokens traded and incur a nominal gas fee.
Deez Nutz
Deez Nutz serves as the guinea pig for the Tiny SPL protocol, providing holders with the flexibility to manage their holdings in innovative ways. It allows users to split, merge and exchange their tokens directly through the interface, connecting their digital wallets. This token is designed to provide a seamless experience for users who wish to tailor their asset holdings to their needs.
Key Features
Holders can split their $NUTS tokens into smaller denominations, allowing for more granular control over their assets. This can be done either as an integer or as a decimal, with a minimum split of 1. This feature is particularly useful for users who wish to allocate their assets or manage them more efficiently.
Users can choose to consolidate their $NUTS balances, up to 50 token balances at a time. This streamlines users’ wallets and simplifies asset management. The process involves selecting the balances to be consolidated and confirming the transaction through their wallets.
The platform offers an exchange feature where users can exchange their $NUTS tokens for SOL (and vice versa) with a transaction limit set at the user’s highest combined token balance minus 1. This feature is suitable for users who wish to diversify their portfolio or adjust their holdings based on market dynamics.
Project performance
Source: Magic Eden, Dextools
The project has not performed as well as expected for the time being, and has fallen by about 50% from the issue price, and the market has yet to be accepted by the public.
Summary
Tiny SPL is currently in the technical experimental phase, with its initial challenges around splitting and merging capabilities having been resolved. The protocol’s ability to reduce storage costs while maintaining the security and decentralization of Solana’s base layer marks a major innovation. However, the actual application and future adoption of Tiny SPL will depend on its ability to meet the needs of projects that require large-scale token issuance without incurring rental costs.
Anatoly Yakovenko, co-founder of Solana, also highlighted the potential importance of Tiny SPL through social media engagement, emphasizing its potential significance within the ecosystem. The community’s response and the protocol’s evolving use cases will further determine its place within Solana’s broader strategy of optimizing blockchain efficiency and accessibility.
Tiny SPL provides an alternative to account deletion by circumventing Solana’s rent payment requirements. The innovation of this mechanism is that it provides token holders with a way to store their tokens for almost free. However, this bypassing of the rent mechanism may be seen as a misinterpretation of the original design principles of the Solana ecosystem. The rent mechanism was established to ensure the effective use of resources and the sustainability of the system. The emergence of Tiny SPL may raise questions about the execution of this principle.
Asteroid is a groundbreaking protocol framework created on the Cosmos Hub through a collaboration between Delphi Labs and the Astroport Foundation. It differentiates itself by allowing anyone to permanently publish data on the blockchain, introducing a suite of tools including indexers, browsers, APIs, and specifications for Cosmos’ fungible tokens (CFT-20), as well as tokens Distribution, foundry tools and comprehensive software solutions. The introduction of $ROIDS as the first CFT-20 token highlights its innovative approach to tokenization and data imprinting on the Cosmos Hub.
Mechanism Overview and Technical Analysis
Asteroid simplifies the blockchain interaction process, enabling users to connect through the Keplr wallet to publish data or mint CFT-20 tokens. This process enables users to interact with web3 technology without in-depth knowledge of smart contracts.
Asteroid operates as a metaprotocol framework, which means it provides a base layer on which other protocols or applications can be built. This scalability is critical to fostering innovation and enabling diverse use cases within the Cosmos ecosystem.
The framework’s ability to support arbitrary content inscription is innovative in the market. It breaks down the barriers that typically require smart contract development, making it possible to publish multiple data types directly on the blockchain. This feature could significantly lower the barrier to entry for developers and creators looking to leverage blockchain technology.
CFT-20 Token Overview
Asteroid provides a new asset creation and distribution mechanism within the Cosmos ecosystem by introducing the CFT-20 token. Fungible tokens are essential for a wide range of applications, from financial instruments to digital collectibles, enhancing the utility and flexibility of Cosmos Hub.
The open source nature of the Asteroid toolkit promotes a transparent and inclusive development environment. By providing exploration, indexing, and token minting tools, Asteroid ensures developers have the necessary resources to innovate and effectively expand the capabilities of the Cosmos Hub.
The introduction of the CFT-20 token expands the utility and interoperability of digital assets within the Cosmos ecosystem.
Making blockchain technology accessible to non-experts is an important step towards democratizing the web3 space.
Project Introduction
Basically, Asteroid Protocol is like the Unisat market of the Cosmos ecosystem, providing a one-stop inscription creation or Marketplace service. Although the track has not been accepted by the mainstream, the project party is still actively building it.
Asteroid’s simplified way of interacting with the blockchain, coupled with the innovative CFT-20 token standard, positions it as a catalyst for the future development of the Cosmos ecosystem. The scalability and inclusiveness of the framework can transform the Cosmos Hub into a central database for numerous projects. Drawing on the catalytic effect of ordi, rats and other inscriptions on the Bitcoin ecosystem, we can expect that CFT-20 can bring the same effect to Cosmos.
Asteroid supports arbitrary content imprinting capabilities, which is an innovation in the market. This opens the door for various data types to be permanently stored on the blockchain. The prospect of this capability is exciting because it greatly increases the scope and depth of blockchain applications. However, arbitrary content imprinting also brings data flooding and quality control problems. Without proper review and filtering mechanisms, the blockchain can be flooded with irrelevant or inappropriate content, which not only increases the storage burden but also reduces the value and credibility of the entire ecosystem.
These protocol standards show the following common industry trends:
In the long term, the adoption of innovations depends primarily on their ability to address core market needs and the potential economic and social impact they bring. Asteroid has the potential to have a profound impact on a wide range of applications due to its emphasis on the participation of non-technical users and the concept of meta-protocol. This emphasis on inclusivity and ease of use may lead to faster market adoption and ecosystem growth. ERC-404 addresses the market’s need for complex asset management tools through its flexible asset ownership and liquidity enhancement capabilities. Although it faces some market confusion and security challenges, its potential market breadth cannot be ignored. Although TinySPL targets a specific problem (data storage cost) of a specific ecosystem (Solana), its impact may be more limited, especially as multi-chain and cross-chain operations become the norm.
This article is reproduced from [panews], the original title is “Exploring the complex pattern of semi-fungible tokens”, the copyright belongs to the original authorBing Ventures], if you have any objection to the reprint, please contact Gate Learn Team, the team will handle it as soon as possible according to relevant procedures.
Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed in this article represent only the author’s personal views and do not constitute any investment advice.
Other language versions of the article are translated by the Gate Learn team, not mentioned in Gate.io, the translated article may not be reproduced, distributed or plagiarized.
Every innovation of Web3 protocol standards is not only a technological leap, but also a catalyst for the birth of new models and new asset forms for the entire digital economy. Innovation in standards, especially in the representation of assets, interoperability, and user interaction, provides developers with the opportunity to build more complex, responsive, and user-friendly applications. With the development of blockchain technology, we have witnessed the evolution from single-function tokens to multi-function smart contract platforms, and each step is accompanied by the introduction of new protocol standards and the improvement of old standards.
This Bing Ventures research article introduces new standards in the field of semi-fungible tokens (such as ERC-404, TinySPL, and Asteroids) and related representative projects, and conducts a certain evaluation of these standards.
We believe that the innovation of semi-fungible tokens should consider key issues in four directions, and their performance in practical applications and market acceptance should also be considered in specific evaluations.
By promoting innovation in these key areas, semi-fungible tokens will be able to optimize the performance of existing technologies and platforms, and also open up new application scenarios and market opportunities, ultimately promoting the healthy and sustainable development of the entire blockchain industry.
First, ERC-404 tokens introduce the concept of semi-fungibility. Semi-fungible tokens are a brave attempt to find a middle ground between fully fungible (like ERC-20 tokens) and unique (like ERC-721 tokens). However, this attempt brings not only technical challenges, but also raises questions about market acceptance. Although it theoretically provides a more flexible ownership model for the asset, in practice, this semi-homogeneity can lead to market confusion, and investors may have difficulty judging the true value of the tokens.
Semi-fungibility
ERC-404 tokens introduce a new concept of semi-fungibility to the blockchain ecosystem. By building a bridge between the fungibility of ERC-20 tokens and the uniqueness of ERC-721 tokens, ERC-404 provides a versatile solution for digital assets.
Fragmented Ownership
The standard allows for fragmented ownership of unique digital assets, such as art or virtual real estate. It democratizes access to high-value assets by making them more accessible and liquid.
Independent Trading
The dual nature of ERC-404 tokens and their corresponding NFTs enables independent trading, enhancing the liquidity and utility of digital asset markets.
Each ERC-404 token is intrinsically linked to a unique NFT, creating a symbiotic relationship between fungible and non-fungible assets. The minting of an NFT results in the creation of a corresponding fungible token, and vice versa. The splitting of a token results in the destruction of the associated NFT, while the merging of enough split shares to form a full token triggers the minting of a new NFT.
Lack of Formal Review and Security Audits
The biggest risk comes from the fact that ERC-404 tokens have not undergone rigorous security audits. Without these audits, there may be undiscovered vulnerabilities that malicious actors could exploit, leading to loss of funds or other security vulnerabilities.
The innovative aspects of ERC-404, while promising, also introduce uncertainty. New code, especially code that has not been field-tested, has a higher risk of containing critical bugs or design flaws.
Compatibility
The official ERC standard benefits from widespread support from wallets, exchanges, and other infrastructure. ERC-404’s unofficial status may hinder its compatibility, limiting its usefulness and seamless interaction with the broader Ethereum ecosystem.
The unique mechanics of ERC-404 tokens may cause compatibility issues with existing smart contracts and dApps designed for ERC-20 and ERC-721 tokens. These issues can complicate their use in some applications or even prevent their use without significant modifications.
Community and Ecosystem Impacts
Adopting ERC-404 without going through a formal EIP process could encourage the proliferation of additional experimental standards without proper review. This can lead to a fragmented ecosystem with an increased risk of security incidents due to a lack of coordinated review and auditing.
Part of the strength of the Ethereum ecosystem is trust in its standards and governance processes. Bypassing these processes can undermine confidence among developers, investors, and users, potentially slowing innovation and adoption.
Bakery 404 represents a revolutionary advancement in democratizing token creation in the Ethereum blockchain ecosystem. By leveraging the unique properties of ERC-404 tokens, Bakery 404 provides a straightforward, easy-to-use, and fast platform for anyone interested in deploying custom tokens.
404Bakery’s Innovation
Bakery 404 simplifies the token creation process, making it accessible to a wide audience not just professional builders. This ease of accessibility is critical to fostering innovation and participation in the Ethereum ecosystem.
Main features
Through a streamlined process, users can create tokens by specifying properties such as name, ticker, and supply without writing any code.
Tokens can be deployed on the Ethereum mainnet in minutes, with plans to expand support to the Base and Arbitrum networks.
Using Telegram bots to guide the token creation process makes it more accessible to a broad user base, removing barriers to entry into the crypto space.
Bakery 404 Operation
The platform utilizes a smart Telegram bot that serves as an interactive guide to the token creation process. This approach not only simplifies the experience, but also adds a level of engagement that traditional token creation tools lack. Users are able to make decisions about the characteristics of their tokens through a conversational interface.
Step 1: Start a conversation with the bot Action: Open Telegram and find the 404 Bakery Deploy Bot using the link provided. Purpose: This initiates your interaction with the bot, which will guide you through the deployment process.
Step 2: Create a new Ethereum wallet Action: If you don’t have an Ethereum wallet, the bot will generate one for you. Ensure the provided private key is stored securely. Purpose: An Ethereum wallet is essential for managing your ERC-404 tokens and paying for deployment fees.
Step 3: Fund your wallet Action: Make sure you have at least 0.3 ETH in your newly created or existing Ethereum wallet. Purpose: ETH is used to pay for the gas fees associated with deploying your token on the Ethereum mainnet.
Step 4: Start deployment Action: Type /deploy in your chat with the bot to start the deployment process. Purpose: This command indicates to the bot that you are ready to proceed with creating your ERC-404 token.
Step 5: Provide ERC-404 Token Details Action: When prompted by the bot, enter the name and ticker symbol of your ERC-404 token. Purpose: These details personalize your token, making it identifiable on the blockchain.
Step 6: Add IPFS and Website Links Action: Provide an IPFS link containing the user’s token metadata, as well as a website link for the token. Purpose: The IPFS link hosts your token’s metadata in a decentralized manner, while the website link provides additional information about your tokens.
Step 7: Contract Deployment Action: Upon confirmation, the bot will deploy your ERC-404 token contract on the Ethereum mainnet. Purpose: This finalizes the creation of your token, making it usable for your intended purpose.
Tokenomics
Source: 404Bakery Doc
Token Holder Benefits
Holders of the $BAKE token are able to earn 50% of the revenue from transaction fees on the platform. This innovative model provides token holders with a passive income stream, directly tying the success of the Bakery404 platform to the financial well-being of its community.
Based on the groundbreaking DN404 technology, Asterix Labs is committed to redefining the landscape of digital assets and their underlying standards.
What is DN404
DN404 is a revolutionary token standard that challenges the established ERC404 and was created by a group of cryptocurrency enthusiasts. It is designed to provide similar benefits to ERC404, but with greater efficiency and lower transaction costs. By employing a dual-contract system that integrates an ERC-20-based divisible token share contract and a mirrored ERC-721 contract for unique NFTs, DN404 addresses the limitations of its predecessor while ensuring compatibility with existing token standards sex. This focus on efficiency and security quickly gained traction among developers and users seeking more sustainable decentralized NFT solutions.
DN404 Features
Unlike ERC404, which attempts to merge the ERC-20 and ERC-721 standards into a single contract, DN404 utilizes two contracts that are linked to each other. This approach simplifies the token creation process and minimizes potential vulnerabilities and security risks.
DN404 offers a competitive advantage in terms of transaction costs, with developers reporting average gas savings of approximately 20% compared to ERC404. This reduction is especially important in the Ethereum network, where gas fees can fluctuate wildly.
DN404’s separated contract structure provides enhanced security features, reducing the risk of potential vulnerabilities compared to ERC404’s single-contract approach.
DN404 prioritizes efficiency and security, providing a reliable framework for tokenization and asset management, making it a strong competitor to ERC404 within the Ethereum ecosystem.
Project performance
Source: Opensea,DEXTools
The NFT floor price is 0.9ETH. Although the trading volume is not large, the price of the token has risen more than 10 times since the issuance date.
As the first PFP project driven by the ERC404 token standard, DeFrog includes 10,000 uniquely designed DeFrogs, each of which offers a mix of rarity, artistic value and technological innovation.
Project Performance
Source: Opensea,DEXTools
As the first ERC 404 PFP project, it once had a tenfold increase in the early stage, and now it has fallen back to about two times.
ANON developed the ERC352 standard, a landmark innovation in the NFT ecosystem. This new standard aims to address and overcome limitations in previous NFT standards, including ERC721 and ERC1155, by introducing enhanced liquidity mechanisms, improved rarity features, and support for fractional ownership. The ERC352 standard introduced by ANON is based on the foundational principles of ERC404 and further pushes the boundaries of digital asset management and ownership possibilities.
Key Innovations
ANON’s ERC352 standard significantly reduces gas fees and enhances market liquidity and accessibility by integrating whitelist functionality to facilitate seamless interaction between ERC20 and ERC721 standards.
ERC352 solves one of the most pressing challenges in the NFT space: rarity management. Through complex contract mechanisms, it ensures that the rarity and uniqueness of each NFT is maintained, thus maintaining their value and appeal.
By enhancing the mechanism of token fragmentation, ERC352 opens up new opportunities for a wider range of investors to participate in the NFT market. Not only does this make the NFT more accessible, but it increases the rarity and value of the NFT by locking up the fraction before the entire token is available for purchase.
Project performance
Source: Opensea,DEXTools
The project NFT has no trading volume on Opensea, and the token was only hyped up to a tenfold increase when it was listed. Now it has fallen back to the opening price.
Alphabet leverages the ERC-404 token standard and cross-chain messaging to revolutionize the points ecosystem. Although the background of the founder is anonymous, he also has rich qualifications. Previously held roles on UNICEF’s encryption team and Deloitte’s encryption team.
Project Overview
Alphabet’s mission is to transform the way points programs are implemented, leveraging the ERC-404 standard to promote transparent, efficient and decentralized incentive schemes. This initiative not only seeks to decentralize points programs, but also aims to redefine their usefulness and accessibility on a global scale.
Inspired by ERC-404’s novel approach, which blends the fungible and non-fungible aspects of tokens, Alphabet plans to apply this standard to create a more fluid and versatile points system. The system aims to significantly reduce operating costs while increasing the liquidity and utility of points as incentives.
At its core, Alphabet is creating a new L1 blockchain specifically designed to run the points program. Alphabet’s primary L1 token holders can stake their tokens to earn fees for these programs, introducing a sustainable economic model that rewards participation and supports the ecosystem.
Alphabet also emphasizes community engagement and aesthetic appeal, with plans to refresh its art in the coming weeks. The project has allocated a significant marketing budget to ensure visibility and appeal within the crypto community, attracting key opinion leaders and movements to spread the message.
Goals and Vision
Alphabet aims to shift the paradigm of current points programs from centralized to decentralized, providing the protocol with a transparent and autonomous mechanism to incentivize and reward community participation.
By leveraging ERC-404 and cross-chain messaging, Alphabet seeks to bring traditional points programs to the blockchain, ensuring these incentives are accessible, transparent and efficient.
The project focuses on creating a gas fee efficient and composable ERC-404 standard that can be seamlessly integrated into different protocols and blockchains, facilitating a universal system for earning and distributing on-chain points.
Project performance
Source: Opensea,DEXTools
The project NFT has only a small amount of trading volume on Opensea, and the token was only hyped up to a tenfold increase when it was listed, and now it has fallen back to the opening price.
In October 2021, the Shib community introduced its first NFT collection, Shiboshis, including 10,000 male characters. Recently, SHEboshis marks an innovation in the women and NFT space, strongly supporting the future of NFTs within the Shib ecosystem. SHEboshis were developed using ERC-404 technology and are designed to expand the functionality and inclusivity of the Shib NFT space.
Mechanism
SHEboshis offer a unique distribution mechanism based on the number and length of Shiboshis held by a user, with Leash holders having priority when purchasing. However, due to a contract vulnerability, the initial phase was skipped and went straight to the public sale. These tokens, built on ERC-404 technology, are tradable and will be traded on Uniswap and Shibaswap.
Pairing Mechanism
Shib plans to introduce a pairing mechanism between Shiboshi and SHEboshis, implying the generation of future generations of NFTs/tokens. Specific details of this output have not yet been made public, with the feature expected to launch within the year.
Integration into Shiboshi Game
Similar to Shiboshis, SHEboshis will play a role in the Shiboshi game, a strategy game utilizing NFTs within the Shib ecosystem. This integration emphasizes the equal status and underlying value alignment between Shiboshis and SHEboshis.
Project performance
As a product officially launched by Shib, it is expected that there will be continued empowerment in the future, and the first generation of NFT series Shiboshis There was also a good increase in the early stage. The second-generation Sheboshis are relatively cheap, and the price may recover after the launch of ERC 404 transactions.
MINER is a collection of 10,000 avatars or equivalents made possible by the implementation of ERC-X, an experimental token standard. The standard distinguishes itself by offering a versatile approach to tokenization, combining features from several established ERC standards, including ERC20, ERC404, ERC721, ERC721A, ERC721Psi, ERC1155, and ERC1155Delta.
ERC-X optimizes the utility and efficiency of the token standard on the Ethereum network. Its design facilitates the integration of various standards into a unified framework, allowing a wide range of applications while maintaining fuel efficiency and scalability.
One of ERC-X’s signature features is its remarkable fuel efficiency. By optimizing transaction costs, ERC-X makes it possible to trade tokens with small capital, depending on Ethereum’s gas price. This efficiency contrasts with the recurring prohibitive transaction costs under the original standard, making ERC-X a practical solution for large-scale operations.
Although ERC-X has made significant progress in improving fuel efficiency and reducing transaction costs, this optimization may bring more complex underlying logic. This complexity not only presents a challenge for developers building applications on ERC-X, but may also increase the risk of security vulnerabilities, as more complex code is often more difficult to audit and verify.
ERC-X’s scalability is evident in its ability to support projects of any size, thanks to its flexible token/NFT ratio. This adaptability is further enhanced by its ability to render NFTs as ERC721 or ERC1155 tokens. Such flexibility ensures that ERC-X can cater for a wide range of applications, from simple token transfers to complex NFT integrations.
Although ERC-X has made contributions in improving the scalability and flexibility of tokens and NFTs, this cross-standard integration may also cause compatibility issues. Especially when interoperating with legacy standards and infrastructure, you may encounter unexpected technical obstacles. This requires a continuous update and adaptation process to ensure that ERC-X can run smoothly in the existing ecosystem.
Integrating elements of ERC1155Delta into ERC-X is a key innovation that provides a significant boost to the standard’s optimization capabilities. ERC1155Delta’s extension to the ERC1155 standard enables ERC-X to provide dual functionality; it supports the generation of both ERC721 and ERC1155 tokens, ensuring compatibility with markets that support either format.
Although integrating ERC1155Delta into ERC-X brings new innovations to the token standard and adds dual functionality, the complexity of this design may cause developers and users to encounter difficulties in understanding and using it in actual applications. on the difficulty. Especially for those users who are not familiar with the features of ERC1155Delta, understanding how to effectively utilize these features may require a certain learning curve.
ERC-X’s EasyLaunch feature simplifies the token launch process into just two steps: deployment and liquidity addition. This simplicity is a significant improvement over the more complex processes associated with other standards, which require multiple preliminary steps before adding liquidity. EasyLaunch therefore represents a significant advancement in making token launches more accessible and less time-consuming.
Although the EasyLaunch feature simplifies the token launch process, is it possible that this simplification obscures certain key considerations for token issuance? For example, considerations for liquidity management, security verification, and long-term token economics strategies may be overlooked because of the simplification of the process. Therefore, while EasyLaunch improves accessibility and efficiency, it also requires developers and project parties to be cautious when using it, ensuring that in-depth project planning and prudent security audits are not sacrificed.
Summary
Fragmented ownership: democratization or complexity?
The introduction of fragmented ownership, while intended to democratize access to high-value assets by lowering the barrier to entry, actually increases transaction and management complexity. The practicality of this approach is limited by users’ understanding and adaptability to such asset management, as well as the market’s demand for the liquidity of such fragmented assets.
Independent transactions: liquidity enhancer or potential source of chaos?
The dual nature of ERC-404 tokens and their NFTs, which are designed to enhance market liquidity, sounds exciting. But in reality, this may lead to market segmentation, with one part of the market focusing on traditional NFTs and the other pursuing the new model of ERC-404. This segmentation may lead to liquidity being actually diluted rather than enhanced.
In summary, ERC-404-related projects are still in their early stages. Although in the early stages, these projects experienced a certain appreciation due to the novelty of ERC-404 and the leadership of the leading project Pandora, the price then gradually fell back to near the opening price. In addition, ERC-404 has also spawned new standards such as ERC-352 and DN404. These projects demonstrate the bottom-up self-adjustment capabilities of the Ethereum ecosystem. This community-driven asset management approach has already established its user base. As long as the technology and user experience are continuously optimized in the future, it is expected to build a complete ecological sector.
Tiny SPL represents a new approach to solving the challenge of on-chain data storage costs within the Solana ecosystem through the use of innovative state compression technology.
Background
Solana implements a unique account model that includes a rent mechanism. Unlike Ethereum, which primarily charges transaction fees, Solana also imposes a rental fee on accounts to store data on the blockchain. This rent is calculated based on the account’s token balance and is intended to ensure efficient use of storage resources. Accounts that are unable to pay the rent may be deleted, although accounts with balances exceeding two years of rent are exempted. As technology advances and storage costs decrease, rental costs are expected to decline, although fluctuations in SOL prices may affect the actual cost burden on users.
Tiny SPL emerges as a smaller, more efficient iteration of the Solana Program Library (SPL) token standard. Its main innovation is the ability to enable token ownership without an associated rental cost, thanks to state compression. This approach significantly reduces on-chain storage requirements by leveraging Merkle trees to compress data verifiably into a single hash. This breakthrough has particular application in reducing the cost of minting NFTs on Solana by several orders of magnitude, as demonstrated by Helium Mobile, which minted nearly a million NFTs at a fraction of the traditional cost.
Differences between Tiny SPL tokens and standard SPL tokens:
By leveraging state compression, Tiny SPL tokens circumvent the need to pay rent, addressing one of the main costs associated with token ownership on Solana. NFT section visibility: Unlike regular tokens that appear in your wallet balance, Tiny SPL tokens are only visible in the NFT section, reflecting their unique approach to storage and management.
Tiny SPL introduces a unique token management experience, including a process for splitting and merging tokens. These operations are critical to adjusting the number of tokens traded and incur a nominal gas fee.
Deez Nutz
Deez Nutz serves as the guinea pig for the Tiny SPL protocol, providing holders with the flexibility to manage their holdings in innovative ways. It allows users to split, merge and exchange their tokens directly through the interface, connecting their digital wallets. This token is designed to provide a seamless experience for users who wish to tailor their asset holdings to their needs.
Key Features
Holders can split their $NUTS tokens into smaller denominations, allowing for more granular control over their assets. This can be done either as an integer or as a decimal, with a minimum split of 1. This feature is particularly useful for users who wish to allocate their assets or manage them more efficiently.
Users can choose to consolidate their $NUTS balances, up to 50 token balances at a time. This streamlines users’ wallets and simplifies asset management. The process involves selecting the balances to be consolidated and confirming the transaction through their wallets.
The platform offers an exchange feature where users can exchange their $NUTS tokens for SOL (and vice versa) with a transaction limit set at the user’s highest combined token balance minus 1. This feature is suitable for users who wish to diversify their portfolio or adjust their holdings based on market dynamics.
Project performance
Source: Magic Eden, Dextools
The project has not performed as well as expected for the time being, and has fallen by about 50% from the issue price, and the market has yet to be accepted by the public.
Summary
Tiny SPL is currently in the technical experimental phase, with its initial challenges around splitting and merging capabilities having been resolved. The protocol’s ability to reduce storage costs while maintaining the security and decentralization of Solana’s base layer marks a major innovation. However, the actual application and future adoption of Tiny SPL will depend on its ability to meet the needs of projects that require large-scale token issuance without incurring rental costs.
Anatoly Yakovenko, co-founder of Solana, also highlighted the potential importance of Tiny SPL through social media engagement, emphasizing its potential significance within the ecosystem. The community’s response and the protocol’s evolving use cases will further determine its place within Solana’s broader strategy of optimizing blockchain efficiency and accessibility.
Tiny SPL provides an alternative to account deletion by circumventing Solana’s rent payment requirements. The innovation of this mechanism is that it provides token holders with a way to store their tokens for almost free. However, this bypassing of the rent mechanism may be seen as a misinterpretation of the original design principles of the Solana ecosystem. The rent mechanism was established to ensure the effective use of resources and the sustainability of the system. The emergence of Tiny SPL may raise questions about the execution of this principle.
Asteroid is a groundbreaking protocol framework created on the Cosmos Hub through a collaboration between Delphi Labs and the Astroport Foundation. It differentiates itself by allowing anyone to permanently publish data on the blockchain, introducing a suite of tools including indexers, browsers, APIs, and specifications for Cosmos’ fungible tokens (CFT-20), as well as tokens Distribution, foundry tools and comprehensive software solutions. The introduction of $ROIDS as the first CFT-20 token highlights its innovative approach to tokenization and data imprinting on the Cosmos Hub.
Mechanism Overview and Technical Analysis
Asteroid simplifies the blockchain interaction process, enabling users to connect through the Keplr wallet to publish data or mint CFT-20 tokens. This process enables users to interact with web3 technology without in-depth knowledge of smart contracts.
Asteroid operates as a metaprotocol framework, which means it provides a base layer on which other protocols or applications can be built. This scalability is critical to fostering innovation and enabling diverse use cases within the Cosmos ecosystem.
The framework’s ability to support arbitrary content inscription is innovative in the market. It breaks down the barriers that typically require smart contract development, making it possible to publish multiple data types directly on the blockchain. This feature could significantly lower the barrier to entry for developers and creators looking to leverage blockchain technology.
CFT-20 Token Overview
Asteroid provides a new asset creation and distribution mechanism within the Cosmos ecosystem by introducing the CFT-20 token. Fungible tokens are essential for a wide range of applications, from financial instruments to digital collectibles, enhancing the utility and flexibility of Cosmos Hub.
The open source nature of the Asteroid toolkit promotes a transparent and inclusive development environment. By providing exploration, indexing, and token minting tools, Asteroid ensures developers have the necessary resources to innovate and effectively expand the capabilities of the Cosmos Hub.
The introduction of the CFT-20 token expands the utility and interoperability of digital assets within the Cosmos ecosystem.
Making blockchain technology accessible to non-experts is an important step towards democratizing the web3 space.
Project Introduction
Basically, Asteroid Protocol is like the Unisat market of the Cosmos ecosystem, providing a one-stop inscription creation or Marketplace service. Although the track has not been accepted by the mainstream, the project party is still actively building it.
Asteroid’s simplified way of interacting with the blockchain, coupled with the innovative CFT-20 token standard, positions it as a catalyst for the future development of the Cosmos ecosystem. The scalability and inclusiveness of the framework can transform the Cosmos Hub into a central database for numerous projects. Drawing on the catalytic effect of ordi, rats and other inscriptions on the Bitcoin ecosystem, we can expect that CFT-20 can bring the same effect to Cosmos.
Asteroid supports arbitrary content imprinting capabilities, which is an innovation in the market. This opens the door for various data types to be permanently stored on the blockchain. The prospect of this capability is exciting because it greatly increases the scope and depth of blockchain applications. However, arbitrary content imprinting also brings data flooding and quality control problems. Without proper review and filtering mechanisms, the blockchain can be flooded with irrelevant or inappropriate content, which not only increases the storage burden but also reduces the value and credibility of the entire ecosystem.
These protocol standards show the following common industry trends:
In the long term, the adoption of innovations depends primarily on their ability to address core market needs and the potential economic and social impact they bring. Asteroid has the potential to have a profound impact on a wide range of applications due to its emphasis on the participation of non-technical users and the concept of meta-protocol. This emphasis on inclusivity and ease of use may lead to faster market adoption and ecosystem growth. ERC-404 addresses the market’s need for complex asset management tools through its flexible asset ownership and liquidity enhancement capabilities. Although it faces some market confusion and security challenges, its potential market breadth cannot be ignored. Although TinySPL targets a specific problem (data storage cost) of a specific ecosystem (Solana), its impact may be more limited, especially as multi-chain and cross-chain operations become the norm.
This article is reproduced from [panews], the original title is “Exploring the complex pattern of semi-fungible tokens”, the copyright belongs to the original authorBing Ventures], if you have any objection to the reprint, please contact Gate Learn Team, the team will handle it as soon as possible according to relevant procedures.
Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed in this article represent only the author’s personal views and do not constitute any investment advice.
Other language versions of the article are translated by the Gate Learn team, not mentioned in Gate.io, the translated article may not be reproduced, distributed or plagiarized.